Custom Cakes · Sweets · Treats

Every celebration
deserves something sweet
made just for you.

Handmade from scratch in Marlboro, NJ — custom cakes, cake pops, strawberries, pretzels, Oreos, Rice Krispy treats and more, each order designed with the kind of detail you notice and the care you can taste.

Baked fresh to order
Designed with you, not off a menu
Marlboro, NJ — pickup & local delivery
Loved by returning families
Why Baked By Madeline

Cake day should feel personal

Every order is custom-designed and made from scratch, just for you.

Made from scratch

Every cake, cake pop, and dipped treat is handmade with real ingredients — nothing comes out of a box.

Designed around you

Tell Madeline the vibe, the colors, the theme — hobbies, teams, favorite drinks, milestone ages — she'll build it from there.

Honest, direct communication

You'll always know timelines, pricing, and pickup details up front — no guessing games before the big day.

Cake Styles

A style for every celebration

A starting point, not a limit — every cake below can be customized in color, size, and flavor.

Vintage heart birthday cake

Vintage Heart Birthday Cake

Classic buttercream with elegant piped details and ribbon accents — perfect for any celebration.

Smash cake

Smash Cake

A simple buttercream smash cake designed for sweet and messy first-birthday memories.

Custom hobby cake

Custom Hobby Cake

Themed around your favorite hobby or sport, personalized just for the guest of honor.

Sports themed cake

Sports Themed Cake

Your favorite team, logo, or jersey colors worked into a cake worthy of game day.

Engagement cake

Engagement Cake

A simple, elegant heart cake personalized with your special date — perfect for celebrating the proposal.

Edible logo sprinkle cake

Edible Logo Sprinkle Cake

An edible logo with sprinkle-covered sides — great for teams, grad parties, or big announcements.

Signature drink cake

Signature Drink Cake

A rich, indulgent cake inspired by your favorite beverage, fully customizable to taste.

Milestone moment cake

Milestone Moment Cake

Tailored to any age — perfect for milestone birthdays like the big 21st.

Baby shower cake

Baby Shower Cake

Sweet, customizable designs to celebrate the mom-to-be and the baby on the way.

Gender reveal cake

Gender Reveal Cake

Buttercream cakes with a surprise reveal inside — customizable in color and design for the big moment.

Celebrity inspired cake

Personalized Celebrity-Inspired Cake

Designed around your favorite TV star, celebrity, or personal style for a one-of-a-kind cake.

College cake

College Cake

A custom cake designed to show off your favorite college or school pride.

Sweets & Treats

Beyond the cake

Cake pops, strawberries, pretzels, wafers, Oreos, Rice Krispy treats, cake popsicles, and graham crackers — can all be designed around your special occasion.

Chocolate dipped treat Chocolate dipped treat Chocolate dipped treat Chocolate dipped treat Chocolate dipped treat Chocolate dipped treat Chocolate dipped treat Chocolate dipped treat Chocolate dipped treat Chocolate dipped treat Chocolate dipped treat Chocolate dipped treat
Party Packages

Treat packages for every party size

Mix-and-match dozens of chocolate-covered treats, bundled up for your next celebration. Prices below are starting points — ask about custom designs when you order.

Small

4 dozen · 48 pieces
  • (1) Dozen Oreos
  • (1) Dozen Pretzels
  • (1) Dozen Cake Pops
  • (1) Dozen Rice Krispy Treats
$138+

Large

10 dozen · 120 pieces
  • (2) Dozen Oreos
  • (2) Dozen Pretzels
  • (2) Dozen Strawberries
  • (2) Dozen Cake Pops
  • (2) Dozen Rice Krispy Treats
$360+

Chocolate Covered — by the dozen

  • Oreos$36
  • Cake Pops$42
  • Strawberries$45
  • Pretzel Rods / Twists$24
  • Rice Krispy Treats$36

Prices listed are starting prices. Custom designs, themes, and specialty decorations may incur additional charges.

How It Works

From idea to pickup or delivery

Three steps, straightforward the whole way through.

01

Tell Madeline your vision

Fill out the order form with your date, theme, and how many you're feeding. Photos or inspiration links help too.

02

Get pricing & a plan

Madeline follows up with availability, pricing, and design details so there are no surprises before the big day.

03

Pick up or get it delivered

Swing by for pickup in Marlboro, NJ, or arrange local delivery on the date you chose — fresh, boxed, and ready for the party.

Place an Order

Let's design your cake

Share as many details as you can — Madeline will get back to you with availability, pricing, and next steps.

Marlboro, NJPickup or local delivery — details confirmed with your order.
Order aheadThe more notice you give, the more design time your cake gets.
Prefer to talk it through?Text, call, or email — pick whatever's easiest in the form.

You'll hear back with availability, pricing, and next steps.

Follow Along

Fresh from the kitchen

See the latest cakes and treats as they come out of the oven.